Dear SAU21 School Board Members:
Let me first start by thanking you for your service– I understand the time commitment it takes to serve in this capacity.
I wanted to follow up with you after my meeting with Superintendent Nadeau yesterday, and provide you the information I presented to her. Our conversation was about an hour long, and was attended by two board chairs, and two additional residents from SAU21. I am grateful for the time everyone took to listen and thoughtfully consider what I presented.
One glaring omission from this training is, not having a non-biased Physician, Phd Child Psychologist or Attorney present to answer any questions that could come up from the teachers and administrators that attend. This will leave out important and critical information that the trainer is unable to provide, since she does not hold these credentials.
Below is an outline on what I covered during our meeting. This includes a few items I brought up to the two school board chairs.
I did ask that additional information be shared during the teacher training.
(A) I don’t believe the training is inclusive and could be construed as a hostile work environment by teachers who have a different world view than Seacoast Outright. If we are truly going to be an inclusive school district, then let’s make sure that these kinds of events reflect that.
My focus is always on how to help public schools. One way is to make sure that the primary focus is on academic excellence. It was the “Massachusetts Miracle” (pre-Common Core) that showed Massachusetts children performing at the highest level in the country on national standardized tests. Even on international tests, Mass. students were able to compete with students in Singapore, and the other countries that were scoring at the top on the TIMSS test. TIMSS is a highly respected international test of math and science given every four years. Every board member should be asking if this test is given in SAU21, and if not, why not.
In Massachusetts they focused on teacher training to elevate the quality of their teachers, and their public schools. They used the best academic standards and tests in the country, but also focused teacher training on academics. Here is your template for how to create the best public schools in the state and country. That is how you unify a community and get the support for the schools, budget and personnel. Right now, this community is becoming divided, and will continue down that path unless parents see that you are focused on the most important task which is, academic excellence.
I oppose this kind of training in the schools. It diverts important attention away from the main task of academics, and privately, many teachers acknowledge the waste of time and money used in this way. However, if you are going to go forward with the Seacoast Outright training, I would like you to consider the information I provided to Superintendent Nadeau.
This starts with a list of materials I suggested we add to the training. These materials would bring in additional viewpoints, and information that are left out of the Seacoast Outright training. In addition, some of the slides that will be presented during the training are full of problems, and could be better defined. Some should be removed, as they promote a political agenda.
(B)
(A) Additional Information to be shared during the teacher training:
NH Constitution: https://sites.google.com/site/nhconstitution/article-5
Detransition Diaries: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NVhUoiXGWx8 (full video once it’s released)
US Dept of Ed: https://www2.ed.gov/policy/gen/guid/religionandschools/prayer_guidance.html
Orange County Dept of Ed: https://ocde.us/Superintendent/Pages/Religious-freedom-in-public-schools.aspx
Manchester NH Diocese Gender Identity: https://www.catholicnh.org/community/public-policy/issues/gender-identity/
FDA issues warning on puberty blockers: https://publications.aap.org/aapnews/news/20636/Risk-of-pseudotumor-cerebri-added-to-labeling-for?autologincheck=redirected (FDA Warns of Brain Swelling and Permanent Vision Loss in Kids Taking Puberty Blockers)
Respect Project : Attached file
Here is the outline I presented from our discussion on September 6th, 2022:
1) The way the event was managed. The decision to have the training was decided in Feb. Materials to be used by the trainer were brought to the SAU in August.
Outside organization’s messaging was not thoroughly analyzed or presented to the School Board members for their approval. No survey of parents to determine if this was needed. Administration never told the provider what was required of them or needed. The materials were never supervised by district administrators. What are the main problems that warranted this training? What are the objectives?
2) Is this mandatory for teachers/staff or not? Article 5 NH Constitution [Religious Freedom Recognized.]
Every individual has a natural and unalienable right to worship God according to the dictates of his own conscience, and reason; and no subject shall be hurt, molested, or restrained, in his person, liberty, or estate, for worshipping God in the manner and season most agreeable to the dictates of his own conscience; or for his religious profession,sentiments, or persuasion; provided he doth not disturb the public peace or disturb others in their religious worship.
It marginalizes the faith community working in the school district. No other training scheduled that addresses the religious families in the school.
3) Hostile Work environment /LegalityThose who are required to attend may consider this a hostile work environment that brings up potential legal issues. Because the training does not take into consideration traditional religious families served in SAU21, if those who are participating do not agree with the viewpoints expressed by Seacoast Outright, will get the message that they cannot speak freely, even in a “safe place.” There is no diversity in the viewpoints that are conveyed by the trainer or Seacoast Outright. (Catholic Diocese on Gender Identity)(Video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NVhUoiXGWx8 )(FDA : Warning on puberty blockers) (Respect Project/ U.S. Dept of Ed: Guidance on Constitutionally Protected Prayer and Religious Expression in Public Elementary and Secondary Schools : January 16, 2020)(Orange County Department of Education: Religious Expression in Public School, 2 videos)
4) Content of the material Erik Erikson Stage 5: Critics of Erikson’s theory say that his theory is more applicable to boys than to girls, and that more attention is paid to infancy and childhood than to adult life, despite the claim to be a life-span theory. However, many have found Erikson’s theory offers a useful framework for analyzing developmental histories.**2 Videos Jessica said she’d be showing? Where are they?
( I did not bring this up during the meeting, but I felt it should be mentioned since Erikson is mentioned as a source from Seacoast Outright)
(B) What is mentioned in some of the slides from the Seacoast Training slideshow: My comments in red (notes)
What is Seacoast Outright: There is a call to allyship. Parents need to know that their morals and religious views, will be respected in this.
Today’s Agenda: Breaking down the binary of sex assigned at birth: is more of a political view and not based in scientific facts.
Understanding the role of privilege and stereotypes: Could violate the anti-discrimination law in NH, and is a political viewpoint that is not inclusive.
Group Norms: What is said here stays here, what is learned here leaves here: Leaves parents wondering what is hidden from them.
Foundational Concepts: The Gender Elephant : One political viewpoint, not inclusive of other views.
Gender Expression: Pronouns: No description of compelled speech which could open the district up to lawsuits.
Sexual and Romantic Orientation: US Holidays to consider: Halloween, Thanksgiving, Valentine’s Day, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day: Parents want to know what will be advised when it comes to US Holidays. Will they promote the elimination of holidays? Mother’s day? Father’s day?
Identity Development in Young Children: Many parents do not want any of these discussions with their young children. That needs to be respected and should be conveyed in this training.
Coming Out: There is nothing about the children who are dealing with underlying issues of self esteem, abuse or even sexual abuse, and may also be acting out. Teachers need to know that some of these kids have serious underlying mental health issues. It would be better to add something about these other cases that teachers may not be aware of, and that parents and mental health providers would be able to guide them.
LGBTQ+ Discrimination and Mental Health Outcomes : Statistics that leave out information because it’s coming from a political source rather than a non-biased source. See additional information on how these statistics are manipulated by political organizations below. (C)
Strategy 1: Acknowledge Privilege and Stereotypes: Provide details on Privilege. This will most likely be requested after the training in a 91-a/Right to Know Request. Have this information documented so it can be available to those seeking information through a 91-a.
Strategy 2: Utilize Gender Neutral Language: Using gender neutral terms is becoming the accepted way to make all people feel recognized and respected: This has actually angered mothers and fathers, so widely accepted may not necessarily be true. Address your classes with gender neutral greetings ex. “Good morning folks!”: This is a political agenda to move society to a genderless society. This is exclusive political jargon not inclusive at all.
Practice using they/them pronouns as singular terms during class: Nothing in here about respecting the conscience of your teachers who may hold sacred religious values. This is more of a political agenda that is exclusive versus inclusive.
Strategy 3 Ask and Tell Pronouns: Nothing in here about respecting the conscience of your teachers again, and is exclusive versus inclusive.
Empowering Your Students: Celebrate Pride Week in October, Ensure representation in books, PUt a few small LGBTQIA + flags or stickers in a visible spot on your desk or lanyard: This is exclusive and not inclusive unless this is advice to teachers so that they are doing the same for your Muslim, Jewish and Christian students. How many books on Christian, Jewish or Muslim Children are in the class?
Taking Action Beyond the Classroom: (Sports / Gender neutral and/or private bathrooms and changing areas: This is a political call to action for your teachers from an organization that we are told is not a political organization. How was this approved for the training?
Resources and Sources: Not diverse in any way. Nothing from the Jewish/Muslim/or Christian community that provide sources on the LGBTQ+ children. Statements, resources, ect.
5) Authority of the staff to execute: What authority will individual employees have going forward to implement these concepts? Open up liability. Will guidance counselors develop plans? Will all of this be made public and transparent? Board members can attend, but for transparency purposes, an audio or video tape should be made and posted on the website.
To the Board Chairs: (Notes)
Do you watch the enrollment numbers?
Do you ever survey parents on the culture/climate?
EXIT interviews of parents?
Bedford/TrinityAre there exit interviews of teachers and do you get ALL of those results?
Do you get a list of teacher training each year?
If not, that should be provided to you with a brief explanation on each training. That should include cost/time away from class. Is it focused on academics?
Do you authorize each training ?
Check registry is displayed on SAU25 website each month. Transparency on monthly expenditures
(C)***Additional information: A recent study, published in the Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy by Dr. Stephen B. Levine, found that transgender activists are misusing the issue of suicide for the purpose of pushing “gender affirmation”:
Suicide among trans-identified youth is significantly elevated compared to the general population of youth (Biggs, 2022; de Graaf et al., 2020). However, the “transition or die” narrative, whereby parents are told that their only choice is between a “live trans daughter or a dead son” (or vice-versa), is both factually inaccurate and ethically fraught. Disseminating such alarmist messages hurts the majority of trans-identified youth who are not at risk for suicide. It also hurts the minority who are at risk, and who, as a result of such misinformation, may forgo evidence-based suicide prevention interventions in the false hopes that transition will prevent suicide.
“The ‘transition or die’ narrative regards suicidal risk in trans-identified youth as a different phenomenon than suicidal risk among other youth,” Levine and his colleagues noted. “Making them an exception falsely promises the parents that immediate transition will remove the risk of suicidal self-harm.”
This meeting concluded on one final note. All of those in attendance and those who are for/against this training share one common view, we want all of the students in a safe and joyful environment. One where all children can thrive. LGBTQ+ students deserve to be treated with kindness, respect and dignity.
I think this kind of training could have been handled far better than what has been presented to the board and community. There has been no consideration made towards the religious families you serve or those who share a different viewpoint than one coming from Seacoast Outright.
You serve a diverse community of families, and when children walk into a school, they should know that all are welcome. Bulletin boards, flags or any other displays need to include all students, not just some of one identity. The same holds true for this kind of training. There is nothing on the calendar that suggests any training will be scheduled so teachers know how to better interact with their religious students and families. Inclusive should truly mean inclusive. That has not been demonstrated in any way in this training on September 13, and by the mere fact that there is no scheduled training for children in the religious protected class.
The post SAU21 WOKE Leftist Political Teacher Training: Email to School Board Members appeared first on Granite Grok.